What makes a punishment cruel and unusual

If the historical record points one way, and the text points another, what source of constitutional interpretation should trump the other? When are punishments so disproportionate to crimes as to constitute violations of the Eighth Amendment? Would it be unconstitutional to impose life imprisonment for the first-time possession of a small amount of marijuana? For a large amount of marijuana?

For prostitution? How should the test be framed? What should be the test for determining when prison conditions constitute cruel and unusual punishments? Is a "deliberate indifference" standard appropriate? Is it unconstitutional to confine an inmate to a four-by-six foot cell?

To double-cell an inmate with a chain smoker? To keep cells at 55 degrees? Does the text of the Constitution make clear that the death penalty is constitutional? What should be made of the Fifth's Amendment's reference to "capital crimes" or twice putting " life or limb" in jeopardy? Is the application of the death penalty in this country so rare and random as to offend "evolving standards of decency"? Might it in the future? The Court in Roper said it is unconstitutional to execute persons who were 17 at the time of their crimes?

Are persons who are 18 much more responsible than year-olds? Why draw the line at 17? Top Definitions Quiz Examples cruel and unusual punishment. New Word List Word List. Save This Word! We could talk until we're blue in the face about this quiz on words for the color "blue," but we think you should take the quiz and find out if you're a whiz at these colorful terms. All rights reserved. Further, if a court does impose a life sentence, it must also provide the offender with a "realistic opportunity to obtain release.

In Miller v. Alabama , U. In Ingraham v. Wright , U. This standard was refined in Whitley v. Albers , U. Pelzer , U. The prisoner was handcuffed to a hitching post for 7 hours, taunted, and denied bathroom breaks. The Origin and Early Application of the Ban The English Declaration of Rights of is the source of the prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment.

The Modern Approach: "Evolving Standards of Decency" The practical meaning of "cruel and unusual" has troubled courts for generations, because it is difficult to imagine that any punishment, no matter how barbarous, should be accepted simply because it is "usual. Proportionality of Sentence: Making the Punishment Fit the Crime The evolving standards approach looks not only at the nature of the punishment in each case, but also whether it fits the severity of the crime.

Prison Conditions The cruel and unusual punishment clause also applies to conditions of incarceration. Talk to a Lawyer Start here to find criminal defense lawyers near you. Practice Area Please select Zip Code. How it Works Briefly tell us about your case Provide your contact information Choose attorneys to contact you.

Legal Information. Criminal Law Information. Proof and Defenses in Criminal Cases. Getting a Lawyer for your Criminal Case. Steps in a Criminal Defense Case. Arraignment: Your First Court Appearance. Plea Bargains in a Criminal Case. Legal Elements of Common Crimes. Expungement and Criminal Records. Should I just plead guilty and avoid a trial? Is the public defender a real lawyer? Can I change defense lawyers after I've hired one? How long after arrest do I find out what the charges are?

See All Common Questions. Related Products More. Criminal Law: A Desk Reference.